Sometimes when you’re watching stuff on The Tonight Show, you can’t totally be sure if everything’s true. Have you two really been “buddies for a long time?” Is your coffee mug full of coffee like we all assume, or is it a different liquid? Are you really wearing that outfit on TV right now!?!? Hahaha, burn!

But there’s one thing that we are pretty sure is true: Jake Gyllenhaal l-o-v-e-d spitting on Jimmy Fallon in this “Point Pleasant Police Department” sketch. Or, well, maybe he’s just a great actor and all his smiles were just acting! I guess we can’t be sure about anything in this life. Sorry for the dark turn in this article, and enjoy this video!