At this point Bill Cosby doesn’t have that many supporters, except maybe the Bad Men of the world plus those Cliff Huxtable devotees who choose to dismiss dozens of women’s allegations so that they can blindly enjoy the comedy they grew up with. In the following sketch from this week’s Inside Amy Schumer, Schumer plays Cosby’s defense attorney, who falls into one of these groups (spoiler: the second group is the group that she falls into).

Below, you can watch Schumer’s character defend Cosby via the most powerful argument a lawyer can useā€”the incredibly sound logic of nostalgia.