Conspiracy theories are as old as dirt, but confirming your bat shit suspicions with the help of YouTube videos and fellow commenters is a rather new occurrence.

John Oliver took a break from his show this week because of Jeezo’s resurrection (perhaps the biggest conspiracy of them all), but left us with a lil Easter egg, tipping us off on his newest an most controversial conspiracy theory to date: Cadbury Creme Eggs.

This is an eye opener, folks, but hopefully by the time you’re out of this rabbit hole, John Oliver will be back from his hiatus.